Did you catch Idol last night? I did, although I just wasn’t in the mood to blog it. Funny thing, that: the further this season has progressed, the less I’ve had to say about the performances. Perhaps that’s due to the whole predictability factor — I wasn’t the only one saying as early as Week 3 it would come down to Blake, Melinda and Jordin.
My recollection of last night’s performances:
Melinda Doolittle: Once again, her neck disappeared. Once again, she delivered technically good performances but somehow lacking in actual personality. The whole Tina Turner “Nutbush City Limits” rendition sounded great… but felt much like watching someone trying to be Tina Turner. (Without the same degree of physical comfort, I might add.) And her re-run of an earlier performance — complete with a little bad acting involving her jacket — was so much less engaging than the first time around. I think the repeat was a bad choice: it reminded me of the first time she’d sung “I’m a Woman,” and yet failed to impress.
Blake: His version of “Roxanne” sounded off to my ears. Flatter than Sting’s and lacking in that split-second-before-the-beat timing that stands out in anything by the Police. Loved the Maroon 5 song, though, and I wholly agree with Randy that Blake’s album needs to have that vibe. The Robin Thicke song? Didn’t like it. No, not at all. Then again, I don’t like it when Robin Thicke does it, either.
Jordin: I agree with Simon that the first song’s jazz arrangement marred the performance, but Jordin herself sang quite well. Her Donna Summers tune was uncannily well-done… for a kid who wasn’t even alive when the original blared nightly at the disco. As for her choice to reprise an earlier performance with “I (Who Have Nothing)”… unlike Melinda’s repeat, this one delivered. Pisses me off that a 17 year-old can sing with such power and emotion, but that’s precisely why I’ll be buying her album.
My prediction: Blake will go home. The Zomby thinks the teen vote will keep him there.
What’s your say?






